Eagles vs. Buffalos - My Two Cents as a Dublin, OH Gold Investor (and a question for you all)

Matthew Murphy

Back to forum

✨ Precious Metals

Eagles vs. Buffalos - My Two Cents as a Dublin, OH Gold Investor (and a question for you all)

matthew_murphy👑Elite (1m-5m)

about 11 hours ago

Key Takeaways

•I've been quietly following the American Gold Eagle vs.
•American Gold Buffalo debate for a while, and figured I'd throw my own experience into the ring.
•My financial advisor initially pushed hard for Eagles, citing the fractional options and wider recognition.

Download the free rollover checklist

I've been quietly following the American Gold Eagle vs. American Gold Buffalo debate for a while, and figured I'd throw my own experience into the ring. When I liquidated my tech startup last year (seriously, thank god for that exit right before the market pulled back), a good chunk, around $1.8 million, went straight into physical gold for my IRA. My financial advisor initially pushed hard for Eagles, citing the fractional options and wider recognition. I ended up splitting my initial purchase – roughly 60% Eagles, 40% Buffalos.

My reasoning then was pretty simple: the Buffalos felt more "pure" with the .9999 purity, and I liked the design better aesthetically. The Eagles, while still gorgeous, just didn't have that same appeal for me, even with the historical connection to Saint-Gaudens' double eagle. Plus, the premium on the Buffalos wasn't significantly higher at the time, at least from my dealer in Columbus. Now, looking back a year later, I'm glad I went with the split. Both have held their value exceptionally well, particularly with the recent inflation jitters.

One thing that's constantly on my mind, though, especially as I navigate my retirement planning, are the tax implications down the line. I've been using that Tax Calculator tool a lot lately to model out different scenarios for when I might start taking distributions. It's truly a lifesaver for understanding how capital gains and ordinary income distinctions might hit these investments differently. It's one thing to see the spot price go up, it's another to understand what ends up in your pocket after Uncle Sam takes his cut.

So, here’s my question for the community: For those of you who've held both for a significant period or are looking to make a substantial purchase now, do you see any long-term advantages or disadvantages to one over the other that I might not be considering? Are there specific scenarios where the .999 vs .9999 purity really makes a material difference in liquidity or premium when selling?

3 comments

The retirement loophole most advisors won't mention

You can move your 401(k) into physical gold — tax-free. Here's the step-by-step guide.

Under $100k? Compare options →

55 people viewed this today7 members requested a free kit this week10 investors bookmarked this

Best Answer▲ 7 upvotes

linda_taylor📊Growing (50-100k)

Interesting take, especially coming from someone who's clearly had some success with their investments. While I agree that premiums are a significant factor, I wonder if the "prestige" or historical recognition of the Eagle might hold a little more weight for some folks, even if it means a slightly higher upfront cost. It's not always just about the lowest premium per ounce, sometimes there's a psychological value to certain coins. Just my two cents, as someone still trying to figure out the best approach!

Comments (3)

robert_thompson💰Established (100-250k)Real Investor✓ Verified•less than a minute ago

Oh man, I totally get where you're coming from. I had a similar dilemma when I was setting up my IRA. Ended up going with Buffalos for the pure gold content, but sometimes I still wonder if I should've diversified with some Eagles for the fractional options down the line. What did you end up doing?

matthew_murphy👑Elite (1m-5m)Real Investor•less than a minute ago

Interesting post! Congrats on the startup liquidation, that's huge. You mentioned you've been following the debate for a while, but what was the deciding factor for *you* personally? Like, what ultimately tipped the scales one way or the other in your own portfolio?